NOTE: Royce Bidwell -- who has written game previews for the Grizzly Journal this season -- attended this year's Big Sky Conference men's semifinal and championship games. Bidwell filed this report for Grizzly Journal and its readers.
BY: ROYCE BIDWELL
GRIZ Nation and Big Sky fans, sorry for the delay in getting this posted. Between working full time, and the tournament, I have been going from 5:30 AM to midnight Tuesday and Wednesday. Like the teams, I had no energy left, but well worth it. After taking some time to analyze this tournament, I feel it be best to give readers a mixed bag, of most good, yet bad too, which I feel needs covered. I am going to be critical, yet honest as well.
First of all, thank you to Northern Colorado and Greeley for a great hospitality, organization, effort, and most importantly great environment. An environment which I hope becomes the normal for Northern Colorado basketball/athletics... all the way from the parking lot attendant who greeted and helped me late Tuesday afternoon, to the final staff member that greeted me on my out late Wednesday night.
And as a Griz fan, I appreciated UNC fans letting Griz fans be GRIZ fans.
I enjoyed the friendly banter I experienced with UNC fans. To the UNC fans sitting four to five rows behind the Griz bench, "Thank you" for an even better experience. They did not have a problem with me cheering on the Griz, nor cheering against UNC. In the closing moments it was nice to hear Griz fans and UNC fans interact in friendly tones, as it should be in sports. Speaking of fans, we see the best and worst of fans on message boards. But in this year’s Big Sky Tourney, whether they were Northern Colorado, Montana, Weber State, or Northern Arizona supporters, ALL fans, teams and coaches all were class acts.
As for Northern Colorado, and the Greeley community, be very proud of this moment. It was well earned. Because of your fans, and team, I will be pulling for Northern Colorado, as loud and proud as I can in the NCAA tournament. Speaking of tournament, let's get to the Big Sky Conference Tournament.
As a fan, it was great to see five of six games be tightly contested battles, decided in the final minutes. The outcome was AS expected, but not HOW I expected. Kudos to each team for playing each game with 40 minutes of heart, hustle, and passion. Congratulations to Northern Colorado for being the last team standing.
Montana 57, Weber State 40: If there were ever a game to be titled "The Tale of Two Halves" this would be the that game. The first half was the worst offensive half all year for the Griz, in scoring only 12 points on 3-for-23 (13%) shooting from the field. Despite that, excellent Griz defense kept the game within 10 points at the half, which ended at 22-12 WSU... thanks to holding Weber State to a pedestrian 7-for-27 (25.9%) first half shooting percentage.
Exactly what was said to the players at halftime, we will never know. Whatever and/or however it was said, the Griz responded with a dominating second half. The Griz responded with a 45-18 scoring margin on 16-of-26 (61.5%) shooting, and continued to stifle Weber State from the field, 5-for-29 (17.2%) shooting in the second half.
In my opinion, and as Weber State Coach, Randy Rahe eluded to, Weber State "Ran out of gas, and hit a wall" with about 10 minutes left in the second half. Playing three games in seven days took its toll on Weber State. That certainly worked to Montana's advantage.
Will Cherry, Brian Qvale, and Kareem Jamar all had great games. A timely block and a few baskets from Derek Selvig, all led the GRIZ to a decisive victory. How much more decisive can a game be than ending it with 17-0 run? Well done Griz .
Northern Colorado 73, Northern Arizona 70: In a sense this game was a tale of two halves as well. The 1st half was an exciting offensive shoot out, which appealed to fans. The second half was oen of hustle, grit, toughness, and stifling defense. It only catered to the hardcore basketball junkies, who can appreciate defense and effort. The first half ended 45-43, Northern Arizona on top. Each team shot well, both notching over 50% from the field.
The second half still had a frantic pace, but neither team could shoot consistently enough to pull away. The Lumberjacks hit 10-of-31 (32.3%) in the second half, and only 1-of-11 (9.1%) from dthree-point range. Northern Colorado shot only 8-of-29 (27.6%) , and 1-of-8 (12.5%) in the second half. Each defense played hard with a lot of energy. It looked to me each team had no legs, or energy left going into the second half.
Great individual performances by Gabe Rogers and Cameron Jones, scoring 24 and 19 points respectively, with only 11 combined second half points though. A nice lift off the NAU bench by sophomore forward, Austin Smith was huge in keeping this game close to the end.
As expected, Devon Beitzel led Northern Colorado with a clutch offensive performance with 25 points. Chris Kaba, Neal Kingman, and Mike Proctor played their roles to perfection as well. Proctor's energy led the Bears with eight rebounds, many of which kept possessions alive for his team. Proctor made big play after big play, and big rebound after big rebound, not only in this game, but both games. Proctor's performance separated the Bears from the rest in this game, and tournament.
This difference in this game was Northern Colorado taking advantage and cashing in from the free throw line. Northern Colorado was 32-of-35 (91.4% from the line) compared to 14-of-17 (82.4%) for Northern Arizona.That alone made for 18-point swing in this game. Kudos to Northern Colorado for an excellent free throw shooting display. It was the biggest difference in this game.
Northern Colorado 65, Montana 60: ESPN, the Big Sky Conference, and fans have to be happy. Finally, a host tournament held serve to make the final game. What more could be asked for to start the game? A full house with a great environment sure made for better television. Once the ball tipped off, it only got better. Each team played 40 minutes with heart, determination, and toughness. Neither team gave in to the other.
As expected, Northern Colorado's home court advantage and senior Leadership impacted the game greatly. The Bears’ seniors, consisting of Kaba, Kingman, and Beitzel -- along with Proctor -- led the way. Beitzel hit big shot after big shot in the second half, with 27 points for the game. Kaba and Kingman hit timely shots, rebounded well, and played tough defense. Proctor, once again got timely rebound after rebound, gave his team energy, and was the x factor in leading the Bears over Montana.
The Bears keyed on Montana center Brian Qvale all game, and forced Montana to beat them with other weapons. For the Griz , each game, the other weapon turned out to be freshman, Kareem Jamar. With the absence of an injured Shawn Stockton, and foul trouble, Jamar was put in position to show his versatility and value to his team. His response -- 10 and 13 points respectively -- was just part of the story. In the final four minutes of the first half, with Cherry out due to foul trouble, Northern Colorado pressured the Griz . How would the GRIZ respond without their top two ball handlers? Jamar was used as a point forward to break the press. In his new role, he answered with ZERO turnovers, and kept the game close going into half time. For an encore, what did he do? He only hit back-to-back contested 3-point shots in the final minute to put his team in position to win. He also played great defense, rebounded, and scored in the post. Despite the loss, the Griz had another leader and star emerge in Kareem Jamar. He has joined Art Steward as “Mr Do Anything when asked.” Too bad that Kareem, and the Griz ran out of time.
The difference in the championship was Northern Colorado out rebounding Montana 37 to 26, thanks to the effort and energy of Proctor. Also, Northern Colorado cashed in with a 21-to-12-point advantage from the line. The foul disparity was 29 fouls against Montana to 16 against Northern Colorado. Some of the disparity from the GRIZ being forced to foul in the final minute of the game. The Bears hit the clutch free throws down the stretch, and took advantage of their opportunity.
This leads to some criticism.
Part of the reason for a late report was for me to justify (or not) the officiating I witnessed during the tournament. To be fair, I wanted to find out if I was being skewed by a Griz loss or not. So I took the time to reflect and research before this report. I took the time to read message boards, and watched the games I recorded. During the semifinal games, I witnessed fans of each team comment on how bad the officiating was. I even heard this from fans of the eventual champion Northern Colorado squad. I heard a few times, and agreed, the hope was for officiating to not play a role in determining the champion. Hate to say it, but It played a larger role than it should have in any conference tournament, or game for that matter.
During any game -- at all levels -- officials will make mistakes. For the most part, that is understood, and respected by coaches, players, and most open-minded fans. The least that can be asked for them to call the game the same for both teams. I did not see that being the case in this year's tournament. Teams aside, Big Sky officials need to quit rewarding offensive players for forcing bad shots, or putting themselves in bad position. The defense has done its part, yet time, and time again in the tourney, Big Sky officials bailed out the offensive player by whistling the defense.
Why were certain players allowed to play at full force and -- with often subtle or normally accepted contact... draw a foul? Devon Beitzel made 23-of-27 freethrows in two games. Meanwhile, players like Will Cherry (9-for-10), Brian Qvale (7-for-12), Shane Johannsen (2-for-2), Cameron Jones (4-for-4), Gabe Rogers (2-for-2), drew just as much, and often more contact... yet the whistle was not blown. The disparity in who was being called for what this tournament was evident, and did take away from an otherwise great tournament. It is a shame, seniors such as Jones, Qvale, and Johannssen ended their Big Sky careers as victims of that lopsided officiating, while Devon Beitzel stepped to the line a whopping 27 times in two games of the tourney. Northern Colorado has the talent, coaching, and leadership to have won this tournament without lopsided officiating.
There is nothing that can be done this year. So, the question remains: Can the Big Sky Conference please learn from this, and expect more evenly officiated games from this point forward? It is time to truly let the teams determine the champion, not the officiating. Whether it be regular season, or tournament, can we have games officiated without the ticky tack calls? Can we stop bailing out players forcing the action? Can defenders get a few more charges called?
I am well aware of even bigger conferences having badly officiated games, it happens. The difference is, the badly officiated games are the exception, not the norm in those conferences. Well officiated Big Sky Conference games have to somehow become the norm as well. How that is done is not for me to determine. If the conference wants to build a conference with truly better basketball, better officiating would be a great start.
I hope Big Sky officials are reading message boards, fan forums, etc. to see our teams deserve better and more consistent officiating. If that is not enough, they need to take the time to review game videos from our conference games, then compare those videos to bigger conference game videos, and learn how to make officiating better.
One of my major conclusions after watching this year’s Big Sky tourney would be to ask its officials to please take the time to ask for honest feed back from all conference coaches and athletic directors, I am confident the majority of feedback given will echo that of mine. We shall see next season. One which returns some very dynamic players. Who else cannot wait for two years of epic Will Cherry vs. Damian Lillard battles?
Finally, Northern Colorado, you earned the NCAA tournament bid all year. Myself and most Big Sky conference fans will be pulling for you, to be this year's NCAA Cinderella. I hope you take full advantage of the spotlight you earned. GO BEARS!!!!!!!
Recent Comments